Time for the Toronto Maple Leafs to Embrace Youth

Writing for Leafs Nation, John Steitzer recently posted an article titled “Too Green vs. Too Rusty.” In the article, he discussed how the Toronto Maple Leafs have surrounded their core with veteran players to push the team further in the postseason. He also expressed concern about rumors of Toronto eyeing 35-year-old Max Pacioretty, who has only played 56 games in the past two seasons due to injury.

Related: Saad to the Maple Leafs? What Would Berube Say?

The Exuberance of Youth Has Been Missed on Toronto’s Roster

This got me thinking: the one ingredient the Maple Leafs have been missing is the exuberance of youth. Early on, it made sense to surround young stars like Auston Matthews, Mitch Marner, and William Nylander with veteran players to mentor them. But now, these players are seasoned veterans in their prime. Perhaps it’s time to give them younger players to mentor and guide.

Some might argue that young players make costly mistakes, but experienced veterans have made errors that cost the Maple Leafs playoff games in recent seasons. Benching young players after a mistake—or because they might make one—hasn’t worked well recently. Maybe it’s time to embrace a youth movement to overcome their playoff woes.

The Maple Leafs’ Change of Leadership Is a Perfect Time to Switch

With Auston Matthews being named the new captain and officially making this his team, now is the perfect time to switch to a more youth-driven approach. Emerging talents like Easton Cowan, Fraser Minten, Nikita Grebyonkin, Matthew Knies, Pontus Holmberg, and potentially Nick Robertson (if re-signed) could bring a youthful exuberance to the team under Matthews’ guidance.

While the calm, veteran attitude of “Yeah, I got this” has merits, there’s something to be said for the energy of a room full of excited young players. This youthful enthusiasm might be what the Maple Leafs need to flip the switch.

Weighing In: Which Is Better—Youth or Experience?

The debate between relying on youth versus experience is complex. Veterans bring stability, composure, and knowledge, particularly in high-pressure situations. However, young players offer energy, speed, and a hunger to prove themselves, which can invigorate a team.

For the Maple Leafs, a balanced mix might be the best approach. While veteran presence is crucial for guiding the team through tough times, infusing the lineup with young talent could provide the spark needed to overcome past playoff failures. A blend of both could harness the strengths of each, creating a dynamic and resilient team.

Related: Being Nick Robertson’s Agent: What’s the Best Advice?