Next Coach for Maple Leafs Faces a Huge Offensive Challenge

When the Toronto Maple Leaf’s new coach comes next season, whoever that might be, he’ll face one huge issue. How can the team combine offense and defense at the same time? That single issue could be the biggest problem he’ll have to overcome for this Maple Leafs team.

The team can play offensive hockey. And, as the postseason showed, it could also play defensive hockey. However, can they learn to play both at one time?

Related: What Shanahan Has Done Right as Maple Leafs President

Combining Offense and Defense Was Sheldon Keefe’s Biggest Issue

One of the persistent challenges facing the Maple Leafs during Sheldon Keefe’s tenure as coach was finding the balance between solid defensive play and offensive firepower. It often felt like a trade-off, where the team struggled to excel in both aspects simultaneously. A closer look at their recent regular seasons underscores this dilemma.

In the 2021-22 season, the Maple Leafs showed their offensive excellence by ranking second in goals scored with 312. However, their defensive performance lagged, as they ranked 14th in goals against, conceding 252 goals. The following 2022-23 season saw a reversal of fortunes, with the team improving defensively to become the second-best team in goals against, allowing only 220 goals. Yet, their offensive output dropped, landing them ninth in goals scored with 278. The inconsistency persisted in the 2023-24 season, where they once again excelled offensively but struggled defensively, finishing second in goals scored and 12th in goals against.

This pattern continued into this season’s playoffs, where the Maple Leafs struggled to generate consistent offense against the Boston Bruins. Scoring more than two goals in only one of the seven games, they faced a recurring challenge of maintaining offensive potency while tightening their defensive play.

The task ahead for the next coach of the Maple Leafs will be daunting yet crucial: finding a formula that allows the team to play responsible defensive hockey while generating enough offense to score more than two goals per game consistently.

The Maple Leafs Offensive Struggles on the Power Play

The Maple Leafs’ Achilles’ heel during the playoffs was their ineffectiveness on the power play. Despite fielding a lineup of offensive stars, including Mitch Marner, Auston Matthews, John Tavares, and William Nylander, the team converted just one out of 21 power play opportunities. Their 4.8% success rate was the lowest in the NHL playoffs, underscoring a glaring deficiency in their offensive strategy.

Compounding their power play struggles was the coaching staff’s failure to adapt successfully to the Bruins’ defense. Despite repeated failures, they stuck to a stagnant and predictable approach, resulting in excessive perimeter passing and a lack of shots on goal. This lack of creativity and adaptability stifled their offensive potential and allowed opponents to defend against them easily.

Contrasting the Maple Leafs’ struggles with the success of teams like the Edmonton Oilers highlights the importance of offensive fluidity and creativity. The Oilers boast the most efficient power play in the playoffs. In fact, their current success rate this postseason is an astounding power-play percentage of 46.7 in the 2024 playoffs.

As the table above shows, the Oilers can play both offense and defense. By contrast, the Maple Leafs’ static power play made it easier for opponents to neutralize their attacks.

If the Maple Leafs Expect to Experience Success, They’ll Have to Figure This Issue Out

Credit must be given to the Bruins for executing a disciplined defensive game plan that neutralized the Maple Leafs’ offensive threats. They frustrated the Maple Leafs’ offensive efforts throughout the series by forcing Toronto to the perimeter, blocking shots, and limiting high-quality scoring chances.

Addressing the Maple Leafs’ offensive struggles, particularly on the power play, will be essential for the team’s future success. Finding the right balance between defensive stability and offensive creativity will be critical as the team aims to overcome postseason obstacles and achieve its championship aspirations.

The team’s ability to strike this balance will define its fortunes in the seasons to come. It would seem they’ll likely spin their collective wheels unless this singular issue can be solved.

Related: Maple Leafs Coaching Change: Why a Cynic Should Doubt This New Direction